For best results, please allow this file to load completely before scrolling or attempting to access links.


The 35th Annual Phi Delta Kappa/Gallup
Poll of the Public's Attitudes Toward
The Public Schools

By Lowell C. Rose and Alec M. Gallup
Illustration © 2003 Jem Sullivan

Executive Summary
Attitudes Regarding the Public Schools
No Child Left Behind Act
The Importance of Good Teaching
The Achievment Gap
Choice, Public, and Private
Problems Facing the Public Schools
Public Expectations
Miscellaneous Questions
Closing Statement
Research Procedure
Sampling Tolerances
Design of the Sample
Composition of the Sample
Conducting Your Own Poll
How to Order the Poll

Links to Previous Polls
PDK Press Release
Download the 35th Annual Poll as a printable pdf file
(Download Adobe Acrobat Reader from Adobe's site)

TAKE SCHOOLS that have strong public support from the communities they serve. Impose on those schools a major federal mandate that attempts to reach worthy goals using strategies that lack public approval, and you have the ingredients for a failed system. Recognizing the importance of the No Child Left Behind (NCLB) Act and the extent to which it involves the federal government in decisions affecting schools at the K-12 level, those who plan this annual poll decided to focus this year's edition on NCLB. To the surprise of this report's authors, the findings point to the situation described in the first two sentences. While the public sees improved student achievement as an important goal, it rejects the strategies used in NCLB. What is reported in the following pages should be cause for reflection and concern on the part of those who believe that success for every child is vital. We hope that this year's poll leads to a lively debate focused on strategies that will advance that goal.

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

The 35th Annual Phi Delta Kappa/Gallup Poll of the Public's Attitudes Toward the Public Schools comes at a time when relationships at the federal, state, and local levels with regard to K-12 education are increasingly complex, change is the mantra of the day, and money is short in almost every state. Attention is currently directed at efforts to improve student achievement, with special emphasis on those minorities and other groups that have traditionally been less successful in gaining the quality of education needed for future success. These differences in school success have come to be known as the "achievement gap," a gap that virtually everyone agrees must be closed. How this is to be done and the relative roles of the parties involved are, however, matters involving uncertainty and controversy. This poll, the 35th in this series, addresses those issues.

The poll focuses on NCLB, the extension of the Elementary and Secondary Education Act, which became law in January 2002. Some questions deal directly with NCLB, while others address strategies associated with the act's implementation. Since NCLB's intention is to improve the public schools, a number of traditional poll questions -- those dealing with grading the public schools, vouchers, problems the public schools face, the nature of the achievement gap, the challenge of getting and keeping good teachers, and the merits of the current emphasis on standardized testing -- all fit nicely into the poll's focus. Taken as a whole, the results offer significant and timely information about the public's view of the state of our schools and current improvement efforts.

We begin this report with seven overarching conclusions. In each case, we refer by number to the tables in which data supporting the conclusion can be found. We then offer additional findings, followed by a comprehensive set of tables. Readers are invited to judge the appropriateness of the conclusions and to make their own interpretations of the data and what they tell us about the public's view of the public schools.

The authors believe the data support the following general conclusions:

1. The public has high regard for the public schools, wants needed improvement to come through those schools, and has little interest in seeking alternatives. The number assigning an A or a B to schools in their community is 48%, with an additional 31% assigning the grade of C. The number of A's and B's rises to 55% for public school parents and to 68% for parents asked to grade the public school their oldest child attends. The number believing that reform should come through the existing public schools is 73%, up from 69% in 2002, while the number of those seeking an alternative is down to 25%. (See Tables 1 through 4.)

2. The public sees itself as uninformed on the No Child Left Behind (NCLB) Act, with 69% saying they lack the information needed to say whether their impression of the act is favorable or unfavorable. Forty percent say they know very little about the NCLB, with an additional 36% saying they know nothing at all about the act. Somewhat surprisingly, public school parents consider themselves just as uninformed as others. (See Tables 5 and 6.)

3. Responses to questions related to strategies associated with NCLB suggest that greater familiarity with the law is unlikely to lead to greater public support.

4. The public is concerned about getting and keeping good teachers, thinks teacher salaries are too low, and is willing to see higher salaries paid to teachers teaching in more challenging situations. Sixty-one percent say schools in their communities have trouble getting good teachers, and 66% say they have trouble keeping good teachers. Fifty-nine percent say teacher salaries are too low, and 65% believe higher salaries should be paid as an incentive for teaching in schools determined to be in need of improvement. (See Tables 19 through 22.)

5. The public continues to believe that closing the achievement gap between white students and black and Hispanic students is important but blames the gap on factors unrelated to the quality of schooling. Ninety percent believe closing the gap is either very important or somewhat important. The number attributing the gap to the quality of schooling dropped from 29% a year ago to 16% in 2003. In identifying factors that are either very important or somewhat important in creating the gap, 97% point to home life and upbringing; 97%, to the amount of parent involvement; 95%, to student interest or the lack thereof; and 94%, to community environment. (See Tables 23, 24, and 26.)

6. The public is not convinced that narrowing the achievement gap requires spending more money on low-achieving students. While divided on this matter, the public leans in the direction of spending the same dollars on each student. When asked whether the dollars spent on each student should be the same or should vary on the basis of student needs, 52% said the same, while 45% said the dollars spent should vary. And 58% of Americans believe that it is possible to narrow the achievement gap without spending more money on low-achieving students. (See Tables 25 and 38.)

7. A majority of respondents are opposed to vouchers and would oppose having their state adopt them, despite the 2002 U.S. Supreme Court decision stating that voucher plans do not violate the U.S. Constitution. The number of Americans in favor of allowing private school attendance at public expense fell to 38% this year, compared to 46% a year ago. The number opposed climbed from 52% to 60%. When reminded of the Supreme Court decision permitting such plans, 56% expressed opposition to having legislation enacted in their state that would permit private school attendance at public expense. (See Tables 28 and 29.)

Additional Findings and Conclusions

 

ATTITUDES REGARDING THE PUBLIC SCHOOLS

Grading the Public Schools

The data regarding the grading of the public schools are summarized in Tables 1-3. Table 1 provides the grades for the schools in the community, Table 2 gives the grades for the nation's schools, and Table 3 reports parents' grades for the school their oldest child attends. The data show what they have shown every year, and the trend data displayed for every second year, starting in 1983, confirm the consistency of the public's grades. The public gives the schools high marks, and the grades improve the closer people are to the schools. That 68% of the parents give the public school their oldest child attends an A or a B is a truly remarkable approval rating for any institution. Moreover, the grades have remained remarkably steady through the years. In an interesting bit of data not in the tables, 30% of nonwhites, 18% below the total, give the community schools an A or a B. It seems reasonable to infer that this difference grows out of the achievement gap between whites and nonwhites.

 

TABLE 1. Students are often given the grades of A, B, C, D, and FAIL to denote the quality of their work. Suppose the public schools themselves, in your community, were graded in the same way. What grade would you give the public schools here -- A, B, C, D, or FAIL?
  National
Totals
No Children
In School
Public School
Parents
  '03
%
'02
%
'03
%
'02
%
'03
%
'02
%
A & B 48 47 45 44 55 58
A 11 10 8 9 17 16
B 37 37 37 35 38 42
C 31 34 30 35 31 30
D 10 10 10 10 10 8
FAIL 5 3 7 3 3 3
Don't Know 6 6 8 8 1 1

Trend Data: Grades for Community Schools (National Totals)
  2003
%
2001
%
1999
%
1997
%
1995
%
1993
%
1991
%
1989
%
1987
%
1985
%
1983
%
A & B 48 51 49 46 41 47 42 43 43 43 31
A 11 11 11 10 8 10 10 8 12 9 6
B 37 40 38 36 33 37 32 35 31 34 25
C 31 30 31 32 37 31 33 33 30 30 32
D 10 8 9 11 12 11 10 11 9 10 13
FAIL 5 5 5 6 5 4 5 4 4 4 7
Don't Know 6 6 6 5 5 7 10 9 14 13 17

TABLE 2. How about the public schools in the nation as a whole? What grade would you give the public schools nationally -- A, B, C, D, or FAIL?
  National
Totals
No Children
In School
Public School
Parents
  '03
%
'02
%
'03
%
'02
%
'03
%
'02
%
A & B 26 24 26 25 26 20
A 2 2 1 1 5 2
B 24 22 25 24 21 18
C 52 47 52 46 49 51
D 12 13 11 13 13 11
FAIL 3 3 4 3 2 3
Don't Know 7 13 7 13 10 15

TABLE 3. Using the A, B, C, D, FAIL scale again, what grade would you give the school your oldest child attends?
  Public School Parents
  '03
%
'02
%
A & B 68 71
A 29 27
B 39 44
C 20 20
D 8 6
FAIL 4 2
Don't Know * 1
*Less than one-half of 1%.

 

Focus of School Improvement

This question was added in 1997 in an attempt to gauge public support for reform efforts originating outside the public schools. The responses consistently indicate that the public sees the existing public school system as the vehicle within which change should occur. The percentage of those expressing that opinion this year is up from last year and is the highest in five years.

TABLE 4. In order to improve public education in America, some people think the focus should be on reforming the existing public school system. Others believe the focus should be on finding an alternative to the existing public school system. Which approach do you think is preferable -- reforming the existing public school system or finding an alternative to the existing public school system?
  National
Totals
  No Children
In School
  Public School
Parents
  '03
%
'02
%
'01
%
'00
%
 '99
%
  '03
%
'02
%
'01
%
'00
%
'99
%
  '03
%
'02
%
'01
%
'00
%
'99
%

Reforming existing system

73 69 72 59 71   73 69 73 59 73   73 69 73 60 68

Finding alternative system

25 27 24 34 27   24 26 23 34 24   25 27 25 34 30

Don't know

2 4 4 7 2   3 5 4 7 3   2 4 2 6 2

 

NO CHILD LEFT BEHIND ACT

The Information People Have About NCLB

The summary at the beginning of this report indicated that people know very little about the NCLB Act, an extension of the Elementary and Secondary Education Act first passed in 1965. That conclusion is based on the two tables that follow. Table 5 shows that only 24% of the respondents said they know a great deal or a fair amount about NCLB. This contrasts with the 76% who said they know very little or nothing at all about it. A second question, presented in Table 6, asked whether the respondents' opinion of NCLB is favorable or unfavorable. Sixty-nine percent said that they did not know enough to say. As Table 5 shows, public school parents, the group most directly affected, felt themselves to be no more knowledgeable than any other group.

TABLE 5. Now, here are a few questions about the No Child Left Behind Act. How much, if anything, would you say you know about the No Child Left Behind Act -- the federal education bill that was passed by Congress in 2001 -- a great deal, a fair amount, very little, or nothing at all?
  National
Totals
%
No Children
In School
%
Public School
Parents
%
A great deal plus a fair amount 24 25 22
A great deal 6 5 7
A fair amount 18 20 15
Very little 40 37 44
Nothing at all 36 38 34
Don't know * * *
*Less than one-half of 1%.

TABLE 6. From what you know or have heard or read about the No Child Left Behind Act, do you have a very favorable, somewhat favorable, somewhat unfavorable, or very unfavorable opinion of the act -- or don't you know enough about it to say?
  National
Totals
%
No Children
In School
%
Public School
Parents
%
Very favorable plus somewhat favorable 18 17 20
Very favorable 5 4 7
Somewhat favorable 13 13 13
Somewhat unfavorable 7 7 6
Very unfavorable 6 6 6
Don't know enough to say 69 69 68
Don't know

*

1

*
*Less than one-half of 1%.

 

The Strategies Used in NCLB

The public shows little support for the strategies that are an integral part of NCLB as it is being implemented. The tables in this section provide the documentation for the nine statements in the opening summary.

Statement 1. The public believes decisions regarding what is taught in the public schools should be made at the local level.

TABLE 7. In your opinion, who should have the greatest influence in deciding what is taught in the public schools here -- the federal government, the state government, or the local school board?
  National
Totals
%
No Children
In School
%
Public School
Parents
%
Federal government 15 15 18
State government 22 22 21
Local school board 61 61 59
Don't know 2 2 2

 

Statement 2. The public believes the job a school is doing should be measured on the basis of improvement shown by students.

TABLE 8. Under the NCLB Act, a school's performance is evaluated annually based on the performance of its students. In your opinion, which is the better way to judge the job a public school is doing?
  National
Totals
%
No Children
In School
%
Public School
Parents
%
Whether students meet a fixed standard 14 15 13
Whether students show reasonable improvement from where they started 84 84 86
Don't know 2 1 1

 

Statement 3. The public believes a single test cannot provide a fair picture of whether a school is in need of improvement.

TABLE 9. According to the NCLB Act, determining whether a public school is or is not in need of improvement will be based on the performance of its students on a single statewide test. In your opinion, will a single test provide a fair picture of whether or not a school needs improvement?
  National
Totals
%
No Children
In School
%
Public School
Parents
%
Yes, will provide a fair picture 32 32 31
No, will not provide a fair picture 66 67 66
Don't know 2 1 3

 

Statement 4. The public believes a test based on English and math alone cannot produce a fair picture of whether or not a school is in need of improvement.

TABLE 10. According to the NCLB Act, the statewide tests of students' performance will be devoted to English and math only. Do you think a test covering only English and math would provide a fair picture of whether a school in your community is or is not in need of improvement, or should the test be based on other subjects also?
  National
Totals
%
No Children
In School
%
Public School
Parents
%
Test covering only English and math would provide a fair picure of whether a school is in need of improvement 15 14 18
Test should be based on other subjects also 83 84 81
Don't know 2 2 1

 

Statement 5. The public does not believe it is possible to accurately judge a student's proficiency in English and math on the basis of a single test.

TABLE 11. In your opinion, is it possible or not possible to accurately judge a student's proficiency in English and math on the basis of a single test?
  National
Totals
%
No Children
In School
%
Public School
Parents
%
Yes, possible 26 27 22
No, not possible 72 71 77
Don't know 2 2 1

 

Statement 6. The public is concerned that relying on testing in English and math only to judge a school will mean less emphasis on art, music, history, and other subjects.

TABLE 12. How much, if at all, are you concerned that relying on testing for English and math only to judge a school's performance will mean less emphasis on art, music, history, and other subjects? Would you say you are concerned a great deal, a fair amount, not much, or not at all?
  National
Totals
%
No Children
In School
%
Public School
Parents
%
A great deal plus a fair amount 80 80 82
A great deal 40 38 45
A fair amount 40 42 37
Not much 14 13 15
Not at all 6 7 3
Don't know * * *
*Less than one-half of 1%.

 

Statement 7. The public believes that making additional efforts to help students achieve in a school judged to be in need of improvement is preferable to allowing students to transfer to a school not in need of improvement.

TABLE 13. Assume you had a child attending a school identified as in need of improvement by the NCLB Act. Which would you prefer, to transfer your child to a school identified as NOT in need of improvement or to have additional efforts made in your child's present school to help him or her achieve?
  National
Totals
%
No Children
In School
%
Public School
Parents
%
To transfer child to school identified as not in need of improvement 25 24 25
To have additional efforts made in child's present school 74 75 74
Don't know 1 1 1

 

Statement 8. The public does not believe special education students should be required to meet the same standards as other students.

TABLE 14. In your opinion, should students enrolled in special education be required to meet the same standards as all other students in the school?
  National
Totals
%
No Children
In School
%
Public School
Parents
%
Yes, should 31 31 31
No, should not 67 66 68
Don't know 2 3 1

 

Statement 9. The public believes the emphasis of NCLB on standardized testing will encourage teachers to teach to the tests and regards that as a bad thing. (Two tables address this statement.)

TABLE 15. In your opinion, will the current emphasis on standardized tests encourage teachers to "teach to the tests," that is, concentrate on teaching their students to pass the tests rather than teaching the subject, or don't you think it will have this effect?
  National
Totals
%
No Children
In School
%
Public School
Parents
%
Will encourage teaching to the tests 66 64 68
Will not have this effect 30 32 27
Don't know 4 4 5

TABLE 16. If the current emphasis on results is encouraging teachers to "teach to the tests," do you think this will be a good thing or a bad thing?
  National
Totals
%
No Children
In School
%
Public School
Parents
%
Good thing 39 38 40
Bad thing 60 61 58
Don't know 1 1 2

 

Other Questions Directly Related to NCLB

Two other questions in this poll related directly to NCLB are reported in Tables 17 and 18. The first sought to determine whether parents in the community would have the information needed to select a school not in need of improvement if given that choice. Public opinion is evenly divided. The second question involves an NCLB strategy in which parents with a child in a school in need of improvement can choose to have their child tutored by an outside provider selected from a list of providers approved by the state. This choice is limited to students who qualify under Title I's poverty standards. Fifty-two percent of the respondents say they would prefer to have the tutoring provided by teachers in the child's school.

TABLE 17. The NCLB Act allows parents of a child in a public school identified as in need of improvement to select another school in the same school district that is identified as NOT in need of improvement. Just your impression, would parents in your community have enough information about the local schools to be able to select a school that is not in need of improvement?
  National
Totals
%
No Children
In School
%
Public School
Parents
%
Yes, have enough information 47 46 48
No, do not have enough 49 49 50
Don't know 4 5 2

TABLE 18. Now, let's assume that your child was failing in his or her school. Which kind of tutoring would you prefer -- tutoring provided by teachers in your child's school or tutoring provided by an outside agency that you would select from a state-approved list?
  National
Totals
%
No Children
In School
%
Public School
Parents
%
Tutoring provided by teachers in child's school 52 52 54
Tutoring provided by outside agency 45 46 42
Don't know 3 2 4

 

THE IMPORTANCE OF GOOD TEACHING

Getting and Keeping Good Teachers

NCLB requires that every classroom be staffed by a highly qualified teacher by the beginning of the 2005-06 school year. A highly qualified teacher is defined as a fully certified teacher, licensed in the subject area in which he or she is teaching.

The poll did not ask the public's opinion regarding this requirement and whether it could be met; however, it did ask a number of questions designed to determine the extent to which getting and keeping good teachers is a problem. The public believes that getting good teachers and keeping them are both problems for local schools. Nonwhites are even stronger in these beliefs, with 75% saying it is hard to get good teachers and 87% saying the same for keeping them. Looking back, we find that these same two questions were asked in the first poll in this series, in 1969, with 52% saying they felt local schools had a hard time getting good teachers and 48% saying they had a hard time keeping them.

TABLE 19. Do you think your local public school system has a hard time GETTING good teachers?
  National
Totals
%
No Children
In School
%
Public School
Parents
%
Yes, has hard time 61 60 62
No, does not 37 36 38
Don't know 2 4 *
*Less than one-half of 1%.

TABLE 20. Do you think your local public school system has a hard time KEEPING good teachers?
  National
Totals
%
No Children
In School
%
Public School
Parents
%
Yes, has hard time 66 65 68
No, does not 31 32 31
Don't know 3 3 1

 

Salaries Paid to Teachers

Salary is an obvious factor in attracting people to a particular job. Fifty-nine percent of respondents to this year's poll believe that the salaries paid teachers are too low. The trend data in Table 21 indicate that this is an area where public opinion has changed over the years. Thirty-three percent believed salaries were too low in 1969, and this figure changed little through 1985. However, the percentage then climbed to 50% by 1990 and has increased nine points since that time. This is almost certainly a reflection of the growing belief that high-quality teaching is the key to student achievement. This conclusion is reinforced by the data in Table 22, which show that 65% of respondents say that teachers should be paid even higher salaries for agreeing to teach in a school designated as in need of improvement.

TABLE 21. Do you think salaries for teachers in this community are too high, too low, or just about right?
   National
Totals
%
No Children
In School
%
Public School
Parents
%
Too high 6 6 6
Too low 59 58 60
Just about right

33

34

32
Don't know 2 2 2

Trend Data: Teacher Salaries, 1969 to 2003 (National Totals)
  '03
%
'90
%
'85
%
'84
%
'83
%
'81
%
'69
%
Too high 6 5 6 7 8 10 2
Too low 59 50 33 37 35 29 33
Just about right 33 31 43 41 31 41 43
Don't know 2 14 18 15 26 20 22

TABLE 22. In your opinion, should teachers be paid higher salaries as an incentive to teach in schools which have been identified as in need of improvement or not?
   National
Totals
%
No Children
In School
%
Public School
Parents
%
Yes, should 65 64 67
No, should not 33 34 32
Don't know 2 2 1

 

THE ACHIEVEMENT GAP

Closing the Achievement Gap

Previous polls have made it clear that the public understands that there is a gap between the achievement of white students and that of Hispanic and black students. This poll sought to probe further by exploring both the closing of the gap and the factors that the public believes cause it to exist. Tables 23-25 deal with the importance of closing the gap and the extent to which the public sees funding as a factor in achieving that goal. The public has been clear and consistent regarding the importance of closing the gap since this question was first asked in 2001. This year, 71% of respondents say that it is very important to close the gap, and an additional 19% say it is somewhat important. This response is uniform across all demographic groups. The responses in Table 24 indicate that the public continues to attribute the gap to factors other than schooling. Eighty percent indicate that this is the case, while only 16% cite the quality of schooling. Nonwhites differ somewhat, with 33% designating the quality of schooling as related to the achievement gap. This response has also been consistent over the three years, although the 16% this year is actually down 13 points from a year ago. The data in Table 25 indicate that the public believes the gap can be narrowed without spending more money to help low-achieving students. Fifty-eight percent indicate that this is the case, while 39% say additional funding for these students is essential.

TABLE 23. There is a recognized academic achievement gap between white students and black and Hispanic students, with white students consistently outperforming black and Hispanic students. How important do you think it is to close this gap -- very important, somewhat important, not too important, or not important at all?
  National
Totals
  No Children
In School
  Public School
Parents
  '03
%
'02
%
'01
%
  '03
%
'02
%
'01
%
  '03
%
'02
%
'01
%

Very plus somewhat important

90 94 88   91 93 89   88 96 87

Very important

71 80 66   70 80 66   73 80 67
Somewhat important 19 14 22 21 13 23 15 16 20
Not too important 5 2 5   5 2 5   4 2 5
Not important at all 4 3 5   3 4 4   7 1 6

Don't know

1 1 2   1 1 2   1 1 2

TABLE 24. In your opinion, is the achievement gap between white students and black and Hispanic students mostly related to the quality of schooling received or mostly related to other factors?
  National
Totals
  No Children
In School
  Public School
Parents
  '03
%
'02
%
'01
%
  '03
%
'02
%
'01
%
  '03
%
'02
%
'01
%

Mostly related to quality of schooling

16 29 21   15 31 20   18 22 22

Mostly related to other factors

80 66 73 80 64 72   80 75 74

Don't know

4 5 6   5 5 8   2 3 4

TABLE 25. Do you think it is possible or not possible to narrow the achievement gap between white students and black and Hispanic students without spending more money than is currently being spent to help low-achieving students?